A Consistent Source of Energy For Swine Diets - High-Shear Dry Extruded/ Partially Deoiled Soy Meal: ExPress®  

Dr. Janeth Colina

The cost of feed in swine production is more than 60% of the total, and within that cost, energy concentration is the most expensive component (1). Therefore, the definition of energy values of feed ingredients and their contribution to the diet is relevant to decrease diet costs and optimize caloric efficiency and growth performance aligned to the genetic potential of pigs. Feed contains specific ingredients which are the fuel that pigs use for body maintenance and other functions. Although energy is not considered a nutrient, it is required to support all body functions and production (2). Nutritional strategies should focus on selecting high-quality feedstuffs, which are more easily classified according to their better-understood energy concentrations, along with the use of these values toward meeting the energy requirements of pigs.  

The gross energy consumed by the pig is not totally retained because part of that energy is lost through feces, urine, gas, and heat. Therefore, further details of how energy is partitioned are required. Overall, digestible energy (DE) is the difference between gross energy (GE) intake and energy losses in feces; metabolizable energy (ME) is the difference between DE intake and energy losses in urine and gases of digestive fermentation; and net energy (NE) is the difference between ME intake and heat production (1, 3). Net energy is considered the most accurate estimate of pig’s need for energy for maintenance and productive purposes (3) and the most precise estimate of the energy value of feed (1).

Most of the energy, measured in calories, that pigs need can be obtained from starch in cereal grains, such as corn, and by animal fats and vegetable oils, such as choice white grease or soybean oil, respectively. Furthermore, each constituent will be used with a different degree of efficiency which will depend on biological availability of the energy in each dietary constituent, the efficiency with which the pig is able to convert absorbed energy into a usable form to perform metabolic purposes, and the purpose for which the energy is used by the pig (4).

Fats and oils provide high amounts of energy to swine diets; however, there is increased variation in composition, quality, feeding value, and price among sources (5).  It represents a challenge for the nutritionists and the pork industry, which are constantly looking to improve economically important characteristics and rely on feeding strategies to determine dietary energy sources to use. In fact, as an ingredient producer, making high-quality ingredients that have consistent composition and energy concentration should be the goal which involves focusing on selection of energy sources.

All soybean products except soybean oil are included in diets fed to swine to increase the concentration of dietary amino acids, but soybean products also contribute energy (6). In fact, full-fat soybeans contain 4,193 and 3,938 kcal of DE and ME, respectively (3) while soybean meal and its derivatives have low oil content (< 1%) because they are co-products of industrial oil production, therefore, the oil has been removed (7). This, in part, explains the measured energy difference between the solvent-extraction method and other available technologies to process soybeans.

Besides being an effective method of processing to deactivate antinutrients, such as trypsin inhibitors in soybeans, high-shear dry extrusion causes physical changes to natural soy components which are associated with greater energy concentration in the soymeal. Indeed, in the native state, soybean oil is stored within the soybean’s tissue cells known as spherosomes, then the oil is released through effective cell wall rupture by shearing forces through high-shear dry extrusion, facilitating the subsequent oil extraction (8). The high-shear extruder does all the cooking with its high temperature-short time process, while the horizontal press is used only to allow the extraction of about 70% of the oil (via mechanical squeezing) that has been liberated through extrusion. The final ingredient, ExPress® soymeal, is a unique soymeal which provides highly-digestible amino acids and a greater energy concentration for swine, due to a residual oil content in the meal of 6-8%, and also because the dry extrusion process liberates more available energy (9).

Concentrations of ME and NE in ExPress® are 609 and 542 kcal/kg respectively more than solvent-extracted soybean meal (9). This difference has been attributed to the thorough cell-wall rupture produced by high-shear dry extrusion and because fat produces more energy and less metabolic heat production, and thus greater animal production efficiency, than starch or proteins. Because of the greater concentration of ME and NE due to 6-8% residual oil content in ExPress® soymeal, it is evident that the energy value of soybeans is increased by high-shear dry extrusion followed by mechanical oil pressing rather than solvent-extraction. Along with accurate knowledge of energy values, other sources of oils or fats of variable composition can be removed from the diet, which can be formulated properly with ExPress® soymeal according to the requirements. Additionally, by getting both protein and oil in one ingredient versus having to supplement the diet with additional fat or oil, diet costs can be reduced as well.

When adjusting the ME values based on the higher residual oil of ExPress® soymeal, growing-finishing pigs use the available energy more efficiently, which is reflected in improved gain/feed  and  less feed intake, when compared to pigs fed solvent-extracted SBM (10). Data from that study (10) and commercial operations have demonstrated that pigs fed ExPress® from the nursery to finishing phase consumed 24.4 lbs less of total feed/pig. In fact, reduced NE levels in swine diets offers the alternative to decrease energy levels if pigs can increase feed intake to compensate it (11).

Overall, the energy value of soybeans is increased by high-shear dry extrusion followed by mechanical oil pressing, and this is a method (ExPress®) to produce a high-quality soymeal with consistent energy value for swine diets. When comparing it to the solvent extraction process, the goal of which is to remove all the oil, versus the mechanical process which leaves residual oil in the meal, it makes a big difference in terms of formulating those diets efficiently and often more economically.  When the proper procedures of extrusion-mechanical pressing are adhered to, the consistent quality of ExPress® meal can be predicted and precisely added to swine diets.

Recommendations

  • Simplify swine diets and reduce overall diet costs by replacing fats/oils of variable composition and quality with a single ingredient - ExPress® soymeal - which contains residual oil in the meal. 
  • Add a consistent high-quality soymeal to adjust the energy concentration of swine diets, according to nutrient requirements, without affecting growth performance and carcass characteristics.
References:
  1. Noblet J. and Van Milgen J. 2013. Energy and energy metabolism in swine. In: L. Chiba editor, Sustainable swine Nutrition. p. 23-57.
  2. https://www.asi.k-state.edu/research-and-extension/swine/swinenutritionguide/energy.html
  3. NRC. 2012. Nutrient Requirements of Swine. 12th edition. Natl. Acad. Press, Washington, DC.
  4. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Feed%2C-caloric-and-financial-efficiency.-Patience/eb7ba1c168326795a3fa9727aa1e53ebe5424b75
  5. https://jasbsci.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40104-015-0005-4
  6. https://nutrition.ansci.illinois.edu/sites/default/files/2NutritionalPropertiesandFeedingValuesofSoybeansandTheirCoproducts.pdf
  7. Nutritional value of soy products fed to pigs. SwineFocus004.pdf (illinois.edu).
  8. Nelson, A. I. et al. 1987. Dry extrusion as an aid to mechanical expelling of oil from soybeans. J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 64:1341–1347. doi:10.1007/ BF02540794
  9. J. Anim. Sci.2020. 98:1-7. https://doi.org/10.1093/jas/skaa215
  10. J. Anim. Sci. 2003;81(8):2032-40. DOI: 10.2527/2003.8182032x
  11. Low net energy diets may result in lower feed costs while supporting swine production (feednavigator.com)